• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Polar Bear Ice Cream - Matamoras: Delicious, Affordable Ice Cream with a Wide Flavor Selection

Polar Bear Ice Cream in Matamoras is a beloved local spot known for its extensive variety of flavors and friendly, quick service. Nestled at 1004 Pennsylvania Ave, it offers a clean, inviting space with social distancing well-managed and a covered picnic area perfect for gatherings after a day at nearby Airport Park. Its generous portions, especially the specialty shakes like strawberry peanut butter, delight families and longtime fans alike. While the cash-only policy can be a minor hurdle, the overall experience—fresh, flavorful ice cream served by enthusiastic staff—makes Polar Bear a refreshing treat worth the wait on a warm day.

Polar Bear Ice Cream - Matamoras at a glance

  • Address 1004 Pennsylvania Ave, Matamoras, PA 18336, United States
  • Phone +1 570-491-4311
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Polar Bear Ice Cream - Matamoras: Reviews & Ratings

Roseanne Carlo
5

Great place. Every flavor you can imagine. Quick service, social distancing lines are clear. Everything inside looks spotless. Really great spot.

Chloe Evelyn
4

Affordable ice cream spot I’ve been coming to since I was a child. Ice cream always very good. Now im taking my own kids w/ their friends! Great place to go for a social gathering with some friends after a game at airport park. Even when it’s busy, the line goes quickly. I like the covered picnic table area available to enjoy ice cream. One star off for only taking cash.

Nick C
4

Good spot for icecream. There was a bit of a line when we showed up but it wasn't the end of the world. They have a lot of flavors and options which is nice. The "small" was actually pretty big / generous. Bill came to about $20 for the 5 of us (see picture). Will happily come back again.

Felix Bennett
5

Excellent stop for a cold, summer treat! The young people working always seem like they are enjoying themselves, and the strawberry/peanut butter milskakes is The Bomb (my family says the other stuff is delicious, too!). If you're in the area, definitely stop for a treat. It's worth the wait if there's a line!!

Location Details
5

Ordered 2 specialty shakes for me and my wife. Excellent choice for a hot day. Price can be prohibitive if you're not ready to chalk up $5 per shake. The server was courteous and clean. I was lucky and only waited for 1 customer before my order was taken so be prepared to wait in line if it's a busy time of day.

Roger Weatherly
5

They were great but they are closed for the season now and will reopen in April 2026.

Laszlo Mohacsi
4

A good old fashioned Drive in Ice cream and Buger joint. Good Ice cream.

J O
5

The ice cream is sooo tasty here. the sizes are not quite as big as some other places. Very nice, patient young workers here. They even gave us a ziploc bag as my son lost his tooth while there, yes eating ice cream of all places.

Location

  • Polar Bear Ice Cream - Matamoras
    Polar Bear Ice Cream - Matamoras
    1004 Pennsylvania Ave, Matamoras, PA 18336, United States Hotline: +1 570-491-4311

Nestled in the heart of Matamoras, Polar Bear Ice Cream offers a refreshing escape with its wide array of frozen delights. Located at 1004 Pennsylvania Ave, this ice cream shop is a local favorite known for its vibrant menu and friendly atmosphere. From the classic Ice Cream Cone to the uniquely refreshing Cherry Watermelon Italian Ice and the whimsical Cotton Candy, each treat delivers on flavor and nostalgia.

What stands out most at Polar Bear Ice Cream is not just the variety but the quality and portion sizes. Customers often praise the generous servings that satisfy both kids and adults alike. The Strawberry Peanut Butter milkshake, in particular, comes highly recommended—rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced.

The shop’s commitment to cleanliness and efficient, courteous service creates a welcoming environment that invites everyone to linger. Even during peak hours, the line moves swiftly, and the covered picnic area provides a comfortable spot to savor your treat while sharing moments with friends and family.

Whether you’re seeking a sweet escape after a game at nearby Airport Park or simply craving an affordable, indulgent dessert, Polar Bear Ice Cream stands out as a spot that delivers consistent quality and charm. Just be sure to bring cash, as card payments aren’t accepted yet. Overall, it’s a place worth visiting for anyone who appreciates a good scoop paired with genuine customer care.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Cash only